I’m surprised Mute Witness never crossed my path before because it’s totally up my alley. It’s a horror film set on a film set, so that kind of meta always appealed to me, whether Wes Craven’s New Nightmare or The Player.
Mute Witness is an ode to old school practical horror movie effects, and they still shot film in the ‘90s so film man film cans feature prominently. It also premiered at the Sundance Film Festival so I can imagine discovering it there and digging it, if I were not still in high school in 1995.
It was also a year before Scream so not quite as overt with analyzing the genre itself. But, to have a killer stalking a film production plays with how everybody involved knows how fake killings are staged.
The 4K edition captures the grainy widescreen indie film capturing ‘90s Russia. The highlight is the effective construction of lighting in suspense scenes as Billy (Marina Sudina) makes her escape silently. There’s lots of good blackness when set lights go out, as she wanders through the dark prop house backstage on the snuff film, hides in the elevator shaft and chases through stairwells and hallways.
Alec Guinness’s cameo also holds up as he’s sitting in a dark car in a garage. The Russia night sky is oppressively black too.
The sound is simple but some of the scare stingers get you from behind.
A video essay by Alexandra Heller-Nichols about snuff films points out that even fake snuff films are presented amateurishly vs. formal film. Mute Witness is different. Chris Alexander’s analysis of films within films is my meta jam.
The VHS sizzle real writer/director Anthony Waller used to get financing by hyping up snuff films includes some of Waller’s previous short films. Location scout footage from Boston shows it could’ve possibly worked there. You can see where the studio chase could have happened in a similar warehouse.
The 4K release maximizes Guinnes yet again by showing the entire two and a half minutes of footage he shot, including leader, in two takes.
Waller recorded a new commentary before his latest film, The Piper, came out last year. He shares some even bigger ambitions for cameos than Guinness. He also speaks candidly about some of the problem actors, including one using drugs, during the shoot. The murder victim had some objections to her scene, and even Sudina could be challenging to wrangle. Others made love connections.
There were mishaps, broken equipment, payoffs to Russian government and mafia, and of course the Guinness story.
The production designer and composer give a more technical commentary, but tell different versions of the Guinness story too. The crew’s experience with Russian crew and different terminology, using sheep’s blood in squibs, and other such details speak to guerrilla filmmaking. This track gets into their biographies towards the end because at a certain point they’ve said everything about Mute Witness.